"Our opponents maintain that we are confronted with insurmountable political obstacles, but that may be
said of the smallest obstacle if one has no desire to surmount it." - Theodor Herzl

Tuesday, January 8, 2013

What's wrong with the current Israeli political landscape

        On Sunday night, at a talk with Stav Shafir, number eight on the labor list and renowned social protest leader, she was asked whether the Labor Party was always her bayit politi (political home). As she responded about growing up in Hanoar Haoved, being disappointed by Ehud Barak, and being inspired by Shelli Yachimovich, I was reminded that this term, political home, so ingrained in the Israeli political mindset, is perhaps its biggest flaw.


         The term has come to mean a political party with a leader that looks like me, talks like me, and thinks like me.  This mindset has allowed Shas to claim that they look out for the lower classes while really only representing low income Mizrachi Jews, Yair Lapid to claim he represents the middle class while actually representing high income Ashkenazi Jews, Avigdor Lieberman to gain political clout by making fun of Polish women, and Hanin Zuabi to practice her dedication to Israel by participating in the Marmara Flotilla.

           In other words, the Israeli search for a political home is what cultivates a political landscape with dozens of little parties, each one happy to look out for (or at least purport to look out for) whatever small sector of the population they represent, while ignoring, offending, or otherwise neglecting the vast majority of the country. 


          For Israeli democracy to grow up it will need to shed this mindset. The electorate must realize that a legitimate political party worthy of a vote must represent not a small group of people, but a coherent political ideology and and a clear plan for a better Israel. All special interest parties (including the party representing my own sector of society) are damaging to our social fabric. In a healthy political system, political parties feel obligated to try to represent and look out for the entire populace. Only parties such as these should be worthy of a vote.
 

          The Israeli left likes to pounce on Shelley Yachimovich for refusing to bash the ultra-orthodox and settlers as cash-sucking enemies of the state. But a closer look will show that while she may not agree with their life-style choices, or the government decisions which support them, she sees herself as a future prime minister and them as legitimate citizens of this Israel. Potential future decisions about their fate in Israel will have to be done with a balanced responsibility towards them and the rest of the citizenry. Hate and character bashing will not help.

        
          To Ms. Yachimovich I say Kol Hakavod  for offering the Labor Party as a potential political home to nearly all Israelis.

         To the Israeli electorate, I say: stop searching for the leader who reminds you of yourself, and start looking of the party who will take this country in a better direction.


-Ilan, an oleh from the United States

No comments:

Post a Comment